“To
sum up, each one of you is to love his wife as himself, and the wife is to
respect her husband.” Ephesians 5:33
When
Lindsay and I got married almost 2 years ago (October 22 J) we received at least 3 copies of “Love
and Respect” by Dr. Emerson Eggerichs. I had heard a lot about this book, but
never took the time to actually read it, until this past month. “Love and
Respect” is in three parts: 1) The Crazy Cycle, 2) The Energizing Cycle, and 3)
The Rewarded Cycle. As I read Part One, I began to take issue with some of the
things Dr. Eggerichs was saying (see below for a few them). I kept reading
though, hoping to find something encouraging and beneficial in this book. Part Two
was better. It had two sets of chapters—one designed for husbands to better
understand their wives, and another designed for wives to better understand
their husbands. There were some very good observations made and tips on how to
be a better spouse. Part Three I found to be very good (FINALLY!). Dr.
Eggerichs finally began to make some sense of all the comments he had brushed
through in Part One.
The
reason I especially like Part Three was because the entire time I had one
question: So what if I do not get what I “need” from my spouse? Even if I obey
God and show all the Love/Respect to them in the world and still see no
improvement in my marriage – then what? (Based on some other things Dr.
Eggerichs had been saying, I had my doubts I would like his answer.)
I
took issue with some of the following ideas:
1)
The “Love and Respect”
idea is based on Ephesians 5:33 (see quoted above). I do not like how Dr.
Eggerichs feels he has discovered some message that has been secretly hiding
for centuries.
2)
Limited presence of Scripture. While there was Scripture
present, it was secluded (mostly) to the margins and most often not commented
on – at all.
3)
The idea of your spouse stepping on your “air hose” which is
supplying you love or respect. Dr. Eggerichs makes it sounds like it is
perfectly acceptable for a spouse to lash out in any way that seems natural
when you are not getting what you “need,” (i.e. “Love” or “Respect”) just like
you would react to someone stepping on an air hose supplying you oxygen.
4)
Dr. Eggerichs description of submission. It was completely unbiblical. Dr. Eggerichs was
attempting to appease the Bible with Feminism – and for that I understand why
he said what he said, but it still is completely unbiblical. He said that men
and women are to share responsibility and authority in the marriage 51-49%. I
take issue with this because of what God says in Ephesians 5:22 and 24: “Wives,
submit to your own husbands, as to the Lord….Now as the church
submits to Christ, so wives should submit to their husbands in everything.”
The church submitting to Christ is the wife’s example. If you take the 51-49%
idea of submission in marriage, then you would also need to do so in the
church. That would mean that the church only has to give Christ 51% of
authority. No one would say that. Christ receives 100% responsibility and
authority in the church. So it should be in the marriage relationship.
***Now hear me out! I believe that
biblically, the husband has 100% authority, responsibility, and thus also
accountability, in the marriage. This does NOT mean that the husband may do
whatever he wants and always get his way 100% of the time. Any good leader
worth his weight in gold will take those under him into consideration. The
husband should always prayerfully consider his wife’s opinion which she is
always free to express, as well as consider how any decision will affect his
entire family. Having 100% authority doesn’t mean you have the OK from God to
make your wife a doormat. She is your helpmeet – one who you lovingly care for.
And the wife lovingly supports her husband’s decisions.
Reasons I liked his
conclusion:
1)
“First, you must get to the place where you can say, ‘My
response to my spouse is my responsibility’” (page 284). Finally! The idea that
each spouse needs to only be concerned with their own response. If we would
only be concerned with our own response in situations, things will be much less
frustrating. You cannot control your spouse to react in good or bad ways in any
given situation. It is our biblical responsibility to obey God and simply worry
about our own reaction. God will take care of your spouse.
2)
“When my reactions to her are unloving, it reveals that I’ve
still got issues…Maybe it is 70 percent her fault and only 30 percent my fault
(and, then again, maybe it isn’t), but the point is, what about my 30 percent?”
(page 284). Again – take full responsibility for your actions – don’t worry
about your spouse’s responses.
3)
This was what really drove it home for me: “In the ultimate
sense, your marriage has nothing to do with your spouse. It has everything to
do with your relationship to Jesus Christ.” My marriage is first and foremost
about my wife and me drawing nearer to Christ and displaying Christ to world. It
is not primarily about my needs or her needs. This is why divorce should not be
the solution. Normally, divorce is selfishly thinking of your own needs. “I can’t
do this anymore!” “My needs aren’t being met!” The purpose of marriage (as is
any relationship) is to honor Christ.
So
in marriage, let us obey Ephesians 5:33 wholeheartedly! And if you get the
chance to read “Love and Respect” do it! There are excellent points! Just do so
with discernment and caution.